There are many sites on the internet describing a typical Xbox 360 problem: the console scratches game discs. Some users are reporting that the scratches were enough to make their game disc obsolete. There hasn’t been much discussion on the fact that the problem exists by consumers, but untill now Microsoft has always somewhat denied the problem and never proposed a solution.
The Dutch television show Kassa, which deals with customer complaints, has been nagging Microsoft about this problem for several weeks, they did tests with Xbox360 setups and filmed (and proofed) that the Xbox360 is indeed responsible for scratching game discs, when not moved, placed on a stable table and under the best possible conditions.
According to the show, the majority of the problems seem to be caused by a TSST drive that is missing parts that stabilize the disc. The problem also seems to be mainly found by consoles produced in December 2006. Estimated is that worldwide nearly 1 to 2 million units are affected.
Thousands of people responded to the show complaining about the same problem and Microsoft simply had to act.
In a press statement the company stated: "As we were not involved with the experiment of Kassa and have little insights in the testing methods, we are not able to respond in detail on the results. It is possible that scratches on discs originate from frequent use. However, we have no indication that the results of the tests from Kassa are a large scale problem.
Of course it is important to us that our customers have the best possible game experience and therefore we take these test results very serious. Xbox owners who think their discs are scratched as reported by Kassa, should contact us. We will investigate the console and when needed repair it so it becomes a full functioning console. We will also inform Xbox owners how they can obtain replacements discs in case they require them."
The television show also reported that while this issue is now an issue in the Netherlands (it is also widely covered in regular news), it could become a global problem for Microsoft in the future. Therefore I would recommend anyone who is facing the same problem to contact their local Microsoft office and point them to this article.
Also Digg this article to make it known to the entire world.
114 Comments
This message was edited at: 17-04-2007 16:05
, damn microsoft, disapointed in the 360 and Halo 3 (Halo 2s twin)..
Also found out that there is a class action lawsuit (actualy 3) against M$ for the disc scratching issue. I hope they get the shaft! :d

This message was edited at: 18-02-2008 14:23
and there are no scratches!!! what the hell is going on??
I was playing assassins creed and i hear this weird noise so i take it out and see these rings of scratches all over it, i got so fuckin pissed.
It was only 2 days old and i paid 40 dollars for that.
Take 2 want £25 to replace it, GAME are not interested even though I paid £270 for the xbox and the game only 3 months ago. Microsoft cut me off while discussing the issue.
Can somebody tell me word-for-word what it says on the sticker that they put on the tray.
Does it say you shouldn't move it with a disc in the tray, or does it say you shouldn't move it with a disc in the tray whilst the unit is on???
The manual mentions nothing as far as I could see and the bloke at M$ couldn't tell me where in the manual it says not to move the unit with a disc loaded when off.
Dagnammit, it pisses me off that they want £25 to replace the media when we all know it's worth more like £3. I'm happy to pay £45 for the game itself, but I've already done that, I don't see how this can be justified.
Bollocks.
...3 mm is enough to solve this problem..
the weird thing is the disc doesnt look scratched but theres some kind of fluid on it reflecting off the disc, i tried to clean it but it stayed on there. microsoft said my xbox is in moist conditions but its in my living room in a dry house in the summer! i though microsoft was a good company because iv got loads of there technology but from there xbox consoles breaking and windows vista system being scrapped! im having doubts. the technology was good in the 80s to 2000 but theres better technologys out there now like apple and sony (playstation 3 and apple systems 4 PC's) hope microsoft fixs there faults
now im shiting ma self

bet your ass i was fucking pissed shit thinking i was gonna have the whole day playing Tales of Vesperia....now i gotta pay another 60 bucks for another copy....dam 360 can kiss my ass....
does this happen if its set straight up horizontal? would it still makes them dam circle on the disc even if it was set horizontal? man if so im trading it back and getting my wii back....shit...gawd!! my precious tales of vesperia!!! 4 dam perfect circles on it man shit!!!!!!!! microsoft i want my money back you bastards!!! fix this dam problem!
The top spindle of the 360 pushes the dvd very close to the tray crater. I took it appart and added a little foam rubber cirle patch on the lower section of the upper holder. This upper holder is the problem.
I know you guys are going to hate me when I ask this question..How could a $20 dvd player not make scratches on movies? Take a dvd player appart and you will see how I fixed my 360...
I am in no way associated with microcrap. I do not run Windows !! only thing I have from them is this 360. I fixed my friends 360 as well to. He was having the same problem.
Brand new xbox360, brand new COD5. Played it for 2 hours, left came back and it wouldn't read disk. Ejected disk and xbox had left a major ring around the disk, destroyed it. Going back to store.
The Xbox 360 hardware is a an insulting joke to anyone with a clue.
i'm not trying to rub it in tor all the 360 owners out there, i'm just thankful I didn't buy one!
Guess we will find out the truth when Microsoft starts tearing apart the dvd-rom drives. But what customer is going to admit it was their fault, or their kids fault on the forums? I also wondering if Microsoft will tell the media what the problem is, if it turns out to be their hardware. I'm curious on the out come.
http://club.cdfreaks.com/avatars/steveo119-375061.gif if you take all the people on here, then multiply by approx 12, then you might get an idea of how many people have been affected by this worldwide, if not more!
Then take that total and divide it by 11, then you might have a slightly high figure, but it is in the non educated ballpark, it doesn't even fit into the guesstimate figure.
Microsoft is the fucking richest company in the world!
Microsoft is the fucking richest company in the world!
Microsoft is the fucking richest company in the world!
Guess we will find out the truth when Microsoft starts tearing apart the dvd-rom drives. But what customer is going to admit it was their fault, or their kids fault on the forums? I also wondering if Microsoft will tell the media what the problem is, if it turns out to be their hardware. I'm curious on the out come.'
now thats the biggest fanboyism i can honestly say I've ever heard!!
is it a case of my toy's the best, so i'm not letting anyone else say otherwise?
you have proven several times on here that you are a fanboy, due to the way you slag off the ps3!! I could easily go on about 'oooh the 360's a crap console coz it dies, or damages disks' but i don't coz A- i'm an adult, and B-I accept that the 360 has got a good games library.
I mean, how blinded are you that you can't see that the 360
IS damaging disks? they've admitted it. and yeah, coz us PS3 owners have nothing better to do than write on here how 'the 360 destroyed my disks'. you're a bigger loser than i thought if thats what you honestly think. what other proof do you want? serial numbers?
I think you've 2 choices here, change the record, or get a life.
Same thing with vehicles. Someone notices steam pouring out of the hood of their car. But instead of pulling over and letting the car cool off, or having it towed to to have fixed, they keep driving the car until it finally over heats and melts pistons and cracks the block. Instead of having a $20-$500 fix, now they have over $3000-$5000 of repair bills. Idiots.
I am a PC person myself. Nothing like upgrading to the latest and greatest when you can finally afford it. The PC graphics and the open source for games make it worth while for many people. Consoles are a bit more stable because game manufactures only have to program for 1 set of hardware, compared to 1000's of different configurations on the PC side. Yeah, I am a PC fanboy...and I am proud of it.
I could afford it back then, but why the hell should i carry on like that when i could be spending my money on things like buying a house, cars, TV's, new sound systems, etc? I understand the satisfaction of keeping a PC uptodate, and getting things like games to work on your pc, but i'm past that, and wantr an easy life! lol
as for your comment about the disk destroying thing, i agree, i wouldn't put another game into a machine if i destroyed 1 i just put in moments before neither, but thats not being stupid, its a lack of common sense. i would be inclined not to buy another 360, and actually demand my money back, and thats not coz i have a PS3, thats with anything thats faulty. hell i demanded my money back when my TV went developed a dodgy line 2cm up from the bottom of the screen, so i see nothing wrong with it myself.
if the ps3 starts eating disks, rest assured i will be putting it up for sale, sell my games off, and wait for the next gen, and still wont buy one till a year later to see if the kinks are worked out.
but hey, thats just me!
If that is your opinion, then you are entitled to it. If you don't like it, then you have to option to not support it. If you are a PS3 fanboy, then good for you. If you hate the 360 or the PC, then again, that is your faith and opinion not to like them. No one is going to change your opinion or my opinion by someone else's opinion. If you like what you buy and you think it is the best and everything else you don't buy is junk, then that is your belief. Who cares what you support or what I support. Everyone is a fanboy of something, even if it is a Ford or a Chevy.
So if your trash talking just to justify why you support Sony and the PS3, then your just waisting your time. Just like I'm waisting my time posting this.
I don't give a rats ass what you believe, and I'm positive you can care less what I believe also. So lets leave it at that.
I'M PISSED OFF!
So now that you guys know practically my whole life story, do you think someone would replace my game, or should I check out the console? Or maybe another piece of advice? Anything would be awesome.
Right now I'm looking into buying a replacement drive from a hack website and hack my 360 so I can run games without worry. I don't have the money for a PS3 or feel it's worth it as a new investment. I don't need it for it's Blu Ray compatability since I already have one on my PC. So spending $400 on a system that plays the same games as my xbox 360 does I would rather just repair it myself.
I'm 31, done it and got the tee-shirt, and i'll admit to being a 'ps3 fanboy' if it means that i defend my own purchase, even though i would drop it like a hot tattie, if it gave me as many problems as the 360 has. and when did i EVER say i hated the 360 or PC?
what do you think i've typed this on?
i've not always been a sony fanboy though, coz i was originally a sega fanboy, having all the consoles since the master system to the dreamcast. I only go for what i feel is the best quality console, so if thats trash talk, then i'm gonna leave it at that also.
apart from this 1 fact. this is a forum style news site, so obviously everyone is going to put their opinions on here, thats what this site is for, or it would be dead. I hope you'll at least agree with this statement.
sorry, i keep getting repeated! lol
Did you call up xbox (microsoft) support? I would call them up and see what they are willing to do for you. Also get a support # and keep it stored for the future. That should be your first step. The final step should be bitching and complaining on forums if Microsoft is not willing to help. Microsoft might just fix it for free, or give you a replacement console and compensate you for 1 disc. That wouldn't be worth complaining to much about, except for the wait.
Keep your support number (or numbers) for future use in case of a court settlement. Post back and tell us your results.
Normally,the newer drives,like the Benq VAD6038 and the LiteOn DG-16D2S shouldn't have this ring of death problem ,so I wonder if you bought some older "overstock " XBox 360
i had a laptop once with a disc in and my friend got mad and started shaking the thing, like in mad, the disc was scratched, but stil readable and doesnt look half as pad as what a xbox does
my current xbox makes a smal line near the middle. this happend after a 4 hour gameplay time. i switched off console to go do stuff, came back and coudnt get into menu.... i only played the game for 4 minutes, and i never touch it and its always vertical
I played Virtua Fighter for less than 10 hours and it got scratched.
On the first Xbox, only COD (which I didn't get brand new) wasn't scratched, all my other games were.
The XBoX has been nothing but trouble... so sad!I should have stuck to the PS2.
WTF was microshit thinking !!!! take out that useless crap. Put a regular Tray.But there is something hidden here .... The Wii and the PS3 system both still have the Legacy mini cdr/dvd slot and they do not have the scratching problem.. My solution for my 360 was to take the DVD rom appart and put a couple of circle open sticky pads on the top counter weight of the dvd rom drive, this way the DVD game wont' come off the holder and spin itself to death. I might try to bring up the dvd holder socket mount maybe about 3 mm higher... Anyways worked for me.. Technicians my ass you guys can't fix crap!!!!
Upto now
All my games still play with massive rings and crap all over the disks but if one ever stops working im going to complain to microsoft.
just bought cod5 brand new and my xbox has just wiped it to shreads lol im very mad. Most popular headlines
Repeat UK file sharers to be banned (2)
- Wednesday 28 October 22:56 by Randomus
- Piracy
Internet users in the United Kingdom accused of illegally sharing copyrighted music and movie files will face stiff penalties, starting with warning letters that will lead to bandwidth restrictions, according to media reports from the UK.
Nintendo to launch larger screen DSi
- Wednesday 28 October 01:35 by Randomus
- Game Consoles
Nintendo is expected to launch a new DSi hand-held gaming device in Japan that has a larger screen, as the company tries to increase sales in the hand-held gaming market it once dominated.
T-Mobile offers no contract phone plan
- Tuesday 27 October 22:46 by Randomus
- Mobile Phones
In an effort to better compete with Verizon Wireless and AT&T, T-Mobile has introduced new no-contract wireless plans that include unlimited voice services.
2 new Roku boxes launched for Netflix & more
- Tuesday 27 October 21:50 by JaredNewman
- Online Video
Roku's streaming set-top set-top boxes now come in three flavors, adding new features as well.
