While Sony’s XCP Rootkit copy protection may have caused enough problems so far, apparently the MediaMax technology Sony uses to copy protect its other CDs can be just as bad as XCP without the Rootkit part. Unlike the XCP copy protection, the MediaMax service is automatically installed, whether or not the user agrees to the EULA. It is also considered Spyware since it ‘calls home’ without the user’s consent and finally, like XCP it also lacks an uninstaller and is rather difficult to remove.
As the MediaMax technology needs to install itself as a kernel service, users can only play these CDs while logged on as an Administrator, which not only hogs system resources and memory as a constantly running background process, but also prevents users at universities and at work from playing these CDs if they don’t have administrative rights to their system.
Finally, in
order to play these CDs, consumers need to use the included MediaMax
player. This player only works with these CDs and vice versa, thus
preventing consumers from using their preferred players, let alone use MediaMax
as a player that plays all CDs. As a result, some consider this to be a
potential security risk since if any security flaws are found in either the
software or the kernel service, the user cannot simply just uninstall MediaMax
to eliminate the security risk,
target=_new>like what happened with XCP, not to mention the risk of using its
uninstaller!
|
One interesting aspect of the EFF suit is its emphasis on MediaMax. Most of the other lawsuits have focused on Sony’s other copy protection technology, XCP. The EFF suit does talk about XCP, but only after getting through with MediaMax. Emphasizing MediaMax seems like a smart move ‘” while Sony has issued an apology of sorts for XCP and has recalled XCP discs, the company is still stonewalling on MediaMax, even though MediaMax raises issues almost as serious as XCP. As Alex wrote last week, MediaMax is spyware: it installs software without notice or consent; it phones home and sends back information without notice or consent; and it either doesn’t offer an uninstaller or makes the uninstaller difficult to get and use. MediaMax lacks the rootkit-like feature of XCP, but otherwise MediaMax shares all of the problems of XCP, including serious security problems with the uninstaller (mitigated by the difficulty of getting the uninstaller; see above). The full article can be read here. |
It looks like the
href="http://www.cdfreaks.com/news/4068" target=_new>felt-tip pen /
href="http://www.cdfreaks.com/news/12718" target=_new>sticky tape method
will start coming in handy when it comes to these CDs, even as a temporary
measure to make a local unprotected copy and then never pop the dreaded CD
in the PC again. Even if Sony or any other music label is forced to
provide an uninstaller for their copy protection software as a
href="http://www.cdfreaks.com/news/12721" target=_new>result of the recent EFF
lawsuit, it will not be of much benefit if the user is forced to install the player each time they wish to play their CD. On the other hand, it will be interesting to see if anti-spyware tools start updating their database updates to recognise these installed copy protection tools and offer to remove the unwanted services, like what some do for XCP. :p
Source: p2pnet.net
4 Comments
Most popular headlines
Grandmother is falsely accused of file-sharing (11)
- Wed 3 Feb 03:00 by JaredNewman
- Piracy
A woman falsely accused of downloading copyrighted movies might've lost her Internet connection had she not taken her case to the media.
PS3 closing ground on Xbox 360 (1)
- Sat 6 Feb 14:00 by Randomus
- Game Consoles
After years of trailing the Nintendo Wii and Microsoft Xbox 360 on the sales charts, the Sony PlayStation 3 continues to close the gap on the Xbox 360.
Blame Blu-ray for lack of PS3 game downloads (13)
- Thu 4 Feb 09:00 by JaredNewman
- Game Consoles
Don't expect Sony to offer its full game catalog for download over the Playstation 3 any time soon.
Murdoch: Avatar DVD won't be 3D (17)
- Thu 4 Feb 00:00 by Randomus
- Blu-Ray writers & players, LCD TV
News Corp. CEO Robert Murdoch confirmed the DVD release of Avatar won't have 3D support, with no word on a possible 3D Blu-ray version.
