Will s-ATA take definitely the place of IDE?

02 May 07 17:08 by geno888 in category Uncategorized To news archive

It is not a secret that all recently manufactured mainboards have only one IDE slot, and this is not really a good news for people with a big stash of burners. In fact, the main issue related with s-ATA controllers is that they are suited purposely to manage hard disk drives (HDD), and not burners.

What is the problem? Simple: optical drives requires ATAPI protocols to work correctly, whereas HDD doesn’t need ATAPI at all. So, controller manufacturers are not implementing these protocols in their hardwares. Consequently, s-ATA controllers have an excellent performance with HDDs but can have a lot of problems to work with optical drives.

Besides a less chaotic cabling, however, currently s-ATA optical drives have no real advantages compared to IDE ones. An example can be found on an article published at The Inquirer, in which Asus DRW-1814BLT s-ATA burner was compared with an IDE drive.

Thanks to GristyMcFisty for letting us know about this news.

 

10 Comments

mrQQ
Posts: 833
Posted on: 02 May 07 18:25
I'm sorry, but what's s-ATA? perhaps you meant SATA..
shuma02
Posts: 72
Posted on: 02 May 07 18:33
Well, it would make sense that a 16x IDE drive is just as fast as a 16x SATA drive.
btspm
Posts: 611
Posted on: 02 May 07 22:56
It's just a chicken or egg issue. Early SATA controllers didn't implement ODD-friendly protocols because there were no SATA ODDs. Now that Intel and the mobo manufacturers are forcing drive makers to move to SATA, the on-board controllers will work to acheive a more balanced HDD/ODD focus.
happyscrappy
Posts: 157
Posted on: 03 May 07 02:21
Say what? I have an nForce 4 SLI chipset. It's, what, 3 years old now? I use a Lite-On LH-20AS1 (SATA) drive on it. Works GREAT. The chipsets that don't work with SATA ATAPI are now so old you can't even get processors that fit on the boards anymore. I agree the performance of SATA optical drives is no better than PATA optical drives. This is the same with HDDs, and yet SATA is doing well in the HDD space. Optical drive manufacturers are having trouble differentiating (i.e. keeping prices up) in the PATA space. Look for lots more SATA optical drives soon. Every manufacturer will jump at the chance to sell SATA optical drives given the $5-$10 price premium.
SithTracy
Posts: 295
Posted on: 03 May 07 02:26
The reviewer should have tried the IDE drive on a Jmicron IDE controller... He probably would have a different opinion.
applegodel8
Posts: 151
Posted on: 03 May 07 04:45
i think they should make a new interface just for optical drives that use a small SATA like cable, but support what the optical drives need to function correctly. i think separating stuff like that makes the system perform better. like when you hook a optical drive and a hard drive on the same IDE cable the performance would degrade, so keeping separate is better, but i hate those big ribbon cables and even with round ones there is still the connector thats big, so how about OATA optical ATA cable. just a thought.
This message was edited at: 03-05-2007 04:46
shaolin007
Posts: 883
Posted on: 03 May 07 16:33
I have an Abit AW9D-MAX and it has 7 internal SATA jacks plus 1 external. Initially, I was concerned about the singular IDE connector but came to realize that it is really all I need. When I assembled my system, I found it much easier to connect SATA HDDs than IDE and the cabling took up much less space. Another concern, was when I was loading the OS but again no problems there either. IDE, your days are numbered.
guest
Posts: 15288
Posted on: 03 May 07 19:07
I wonder why is talking about the SATA replacing the PATA connectors on motherboards. What is bother me is presence of the FDD conector on every motherboard. Not to mention presence of ancient paralel port, serial port and ps2 ports. USB flash memory is more convenient than 1000 FDD, and periferals are conecting today using USB, firewire and E-SATA. The presence of one PATA conector is good for compatibility with old products, but will be eventualy discontinued (i hope so) in 2-3 years.
Jagaer
Posts: 43
Posted on: 04 May 07 18:51
I agree with gogu that the FDD has been long dead, and IDE should be next. I disagree that parallel and serial ports are dead, however. The majority of consumer electronics are now USB, but both parallel and serial are much more useful to hobbiests due to their simplicity. I agree that they are both going to be gone relatively soon..but at least there are PCIe cards for the ports.
guest
Posts: 15288
Posted on: 04 May 07 20:28
I have been using SATA and it is the best. No coaster, fast and quieted. Cable connection is so easy. I loveee SATA

Post a comment

Hello guest,
default
To benefit from all extra features you need to log in or sign up.

Most popular headlines

Grandmother is falsely accused of file-sharing (11)

A woman falsely accused of downloading copyrighted movies might've lost her Internet connection had she not taken her case to the media.

PS3 closing ground on Xbox 360 (1)

  • Sat 6 Feb 14:00 by Randomus
  • Game Consoles

After years of trailing the Nintendo Wii and Microsoft Xbox 360 on the sales charts, the Sony PlayStation 3 continues to close the gap on the Xbox 360.

Blame Blu-ray for lack of PS3 game downloads (14)

Don't expect Sony to offer its full game catalog for download over the Playstation 3 any time soon.

Murdoch: Avatar DVD won't be 3D (17)

  • Thu 4 Feb 00:00 by Randomus
  • Blu-Ray writers & players, LCD TV

News Corp. CEO Robert Murdoch confirmed the DVD release of Avatar won't have 3D support, with no word on a possible 3D Blu-ray version.

See all headlines

Active Commenters