Myce.com Latest Updates

Anti-piracy lawyers caught pirating each other’s work

Posted at 02 October 2010 00:00 CEST by wconeybeer

We would like to think that the lawyers that are prosecuting alleged copyright infringers are practicing what they preach, but it looks like one of the most high profile firms involved in such cases are just as guilty of stealing other’s work as those who are downloading illegal media.

Allegedly, the file sharing settlement letters and follow-up response templates used by ACS:Law were blatantly copied by lawyers at Tilly, Bailey and Irvine, who were starting their own settlement letter operation.

Andrew Crossly from ACS:Law claims that the firm contacted him for help, which he provided, but instead of just using his templates as a guide, Tilly, Bailey and Irvine began to use them as their own without consent.

“My cooperation does not extend to allowing, without my prior knowledge, license or permission, to use my firm’s range of precedent letters, paragraphs and responses. These have been developed over a long period of time and are not available for use by others,” Crossly wrote in an email that was exposed during the recent ACS:Law email leak. “I have worked tirelessly and at great personal financial cost over the past year to perfect my firm’s business model and it would appear that you have chosen a lazy short cut to ape my business model by utilizing my firm’s carefully prepared and bespoke precedents. For the avoidance of any doubt, I have not ever and will not now or in the future grant to you any license to use my firm’s precedents.”

The work that Crossly claims was stolen from him was actually copied from yet another firm, Davenport Lyons, who helped Crossly set up his own business. That firm has since exited the settlement letter business and some staff has migrated to ACS:Law, but Crossly is claiming that he took over business from Davenport Lyons and therefor “acquired all necessary precedents prepared by them”.

Is it really that hard to draft an original letter nowadays that even the copyright lawyers need to steal from each other? And yet they still go out day after day and prosecute others for doing the same thing. What a sad state of affairs indeed.

Click to share

There are 3 comments

TigerZai
MyCE Resident
Posted on: 02 Oct 10 06:40
    Dear wconeybeer,

    Must correct you on a few small but important points.

    After Davenport-Lyons ceased the speculative invoicing game, Crossley left along with several colleagues to form ACS:Law using evidence and templates from Davenport-Lyons with their permission. He didn't steal from them.

    Andrew Crossley was referring to Tilly Bailey & Irvine using parts of his template letters without permission. ACS:Law would not be stealing from Crossley as he is the sole principal.

    Lazy short cuts and sad state of affairs indeed.
    penguin_head
    MyCE Rookie
    Posted on: 04 Oct 10 20:13
      Most people seem to forget the simple rule that when you point your finger at someone, you have 3 fingers pointing right back at you.
      Blu-rayFreak
      MyCE Resident
      Posted on: 05 Oct 10 20:29
        @TigerZai, thanks, we've updated the story.

        Post your comment

        You need to register before you can comment

        Like us

        Most popular headlines

        Windows XP security fix hangs systems and leaves them partly unprotected

        An update to the Anti Malware Service for Windows XP is causing systems to slow ...

        DVDFab decryption only available with paid licenses from now on

        DVDFab has posted a clarification on of their disc decryption policy on our foru...

        Crucial M550 512GB SSD Review - Pure speed

        • Mon 14 Apr 04:04 by Vroom

        Review: Crucial M550 Reviewed by: ANTONIS SAPANIDIS Provided by: Cr...

        Nexus 5 running Android 4.4.3 screenshot leaks

        The Chromium issue tracker reveals a screenshot of a Nexus 5 running Android 4.4...

        Microsoft releases fixes for Windows 8.1 Spring Update install errors

        Microsoft released two patches already for users who received error codes 800700...

        See all headlines
        Follow Myce.com