Myce.com Latest Updates

Can DMCA takedown notices be copyrighted themselves?

Posted 10 February 2011 04:00 CET by Justin_Massoud

Do DMCA takedown notices, those legal writs nobody wants to find in their mailbox,  enjoy the same copyright protection as music, films and video games? According to some DMCA takedown notices making the rounds, they do.

Certain takedown notice companies are actively informing recipients via the letter itself that they should not share it with third parties, as doing so would violate the notice’s copyright. How exactly could these takedown notices, which exist solely to demand a site remove infringing material, claim such a thing?

Good question.

An article at techdirt broached the subject after noticing a blog post by Tom Rubin, Chief Counsel for Intellectual Property Strategy at Microsoft, that included one such DMCA form proclaiming its copyright protection. The entry, simply titled “Anti-transparency,” offers a similarly curt statement in regard to the notice: “This is a step in the opposite direction of optimizing copyright for the cloud,” Rubin writes.

If this sounds a bit like one of those ‘chicken or egg’ scenarios, that’s because it is; DMCA takedown notices wouldn’t exist if not for copyright infringement claims. But who are these “third parties” the letters refer to? Sites like ChillingEffects.org – which collects cease and desist notices and posts them for public perusal – is one such party directly named. In addition to maintaining a C&D database, the group aims to help users “understand the protections that the First Amendment and intellectual property laws give to your online activities.”

MiMTiD, a company that distributes automated takedown notices and allows users to search for possible copyright infringement (think Google for copyright lawyers and corporate bigwigs), is under scrutiny in particular as it’s the author of the notice in question.. Can an automated C&D notice be copyrighted, ponders the site. We’d like to know, too.

More on this news as it develops – so long as we don’t receive a DMCA notice for linking to a DMCA notice that claims it cannot be shared with anyone but the intended recipient.

rla
Banned
Posted on: 10 Feb 11 14:26
Just kind of serves as an example of the kind of mentality you deal with when encountering these industry jackasses.
0 Agree

DrageMester
Retired Moderator
Posted on: 10 Feb 11 14:46
Can posts in threads about copyrighted DMCA takedown notices be copyrighted?
0 Agree

Blu-rayFreak
MyCE Resident
Posted on: 10 Feb 11 14:53
Quote:
Originally Posted by Justin_Massoud
More on this news as it develops – so long as we don’t receive a DMCA notice for linking to a DMCA notice that claims it cannot be shared with anyone but the intended recipient.
Love that last bit.
0 Agree

Justin_Massoud
MyCE Senior Member
Posted on: 10 Feb 11 15:50
Quote:
Originally Posted by Blu-rayFreak
Love that last bit.
I couldn't help myself.
0 Agree

AllanDeGroot
MyCE Resident
Posted on: 10 Feb 11 16:07
If I got a notice like that I'd do the modern legal equivelent of "I double-Dog dare you"
and post it on every web site I could find.

Purely to get them into court and enter that kind of letter into evidence... however briefly before the judge had his clerk make copies for each lawer and hired an oragami expert to fold them so they were all sharp edges before putting them where they would best serve the interest of justice...

(some place moist and dark where it is said "the Sun Never shines")


AD
0 Agree

Post your comment

Myce.com settings

Several settings at Myce.com can be changed, they are stored in cookies, which means they will be reset if you clear Myce.com cookies

Background

Change the background to a plain color or trianglified image (similar to the default image)

No tracking features

At Myce most social media feature are done server side and impose no privacy risk to the visitor when not used. Several features use Javascript with you can turn off here

Layout

Switch to the List layout for an index with chronologycally listed news items or Grid layout for a block based layout. To see the change you need to reload the page

×