European Court of Justice rules against illegal downloads in The Netherlands
The Netherlands has relatively lenient copyright laws when compared to most of the rest of the world, and include provisions for “home” copying. In a suit at the European Court, the Dutch government argued downloading copyrighted materials was equivalent to copying one’s own CD’s or DVD’s. But on Thursday, the European Court of Justice ruled that downloading media files from illegal sources would no longer be tolerated. A spokesman from the Dutch Ministry of Security and Justice stated that this ruling means that downloading from illegal sources is immediately banned.
Dutch laws will not be modified to adjust to this new ruling, but Dutch courts will no longer be able to interpret their laws to allow for illegal downloads by individuals. There is a levy in place on various types of blank media in The Netherlands, intended to cover the “loss” of revenue from individual home copying. Several companies brought this suit to the European court, including Sony and Philips, contending that the home copy provisions did not adequately cover losses from downloaded material, and the European Court agreed with them.
No individual downloaders will face prosecution in The Netherlands as a result of this ruling however. Illegal downloads are seen as a civil violation, not a criminal one. And copyright watchdog groups like Brein, say that they will focus their attention on those who upload large amounts of copyrighted works, rather than attempt to go after individuals who download such materials.
If you read Dutch, here is the link to the story at Tweakers.net.
Google translate will have to do for those who wish to view the story in English.
Discuss this in our related forum
Click for more newspiracycopyright law
Click to share
There are 4 comments
- MyCE Senior Member
- Posted on: 10 Apr 14 22:46
- MyCE Rookie
- Posted on: 11 Apr 14 03:03
Not really, if you live in EU choose The Netherlands, because as you can read, they obey the EU and now say that is illegal, but they wont do anything about it, except "focus their attention on those who upload large amounts of copyrighted works". How much is large amounts? And downloaders as you can read "No individual downloaders will face prosecution in The Netherlands as a result of this ruling".
- Posted on: 11 Apr 14 03:57
And no prosecution for individuals means no criminal charges...it doesn't necessarily rule out civil suits by movie studios, recording studios and the like.
- MyCE Resident
- Posted on: 11 Apr 14 23:59
Most popular headlines
- Tue 18 Nov 12:11 by DoMiN8ToR
Users on the Android Issue Tracker report a SMS bug in Android 5.0 Lollipop runn...
- Fri 21 Nov 07:11 by DoMiN8ToR
Intel plans to release SSDs based on 3D NAND in 2015 with "disruptive cost&...
- Fri 21 Nov 06:11 by DoMiN8ToR
Antivirus test organisation Virus Bulletin has tested 48 virus scanners for Wind...
- Sat 22 Nov 12:11 by DoMiN8ToR
A recent update to Windows 8.1 causes issues with Avast antivirus. U...
- Mon 17 Nov 04:11 by DoMiN8ToR
An important update Microsoft released last Tuesday fixing a critical vulnerabil...