Myce.com Latest Updates

Fake and counterfeit USB flash drives spreading on Amazon

Posted at 04 July 2014 23:02 CEST by Seán Byrne

Over the past few years, eBay has been flooded with what appears to be bargain USB flash drives and memory cards priced as little as 1/10th the price of an equivalent capacity drive sold by a reputable dealer. However, the vast majority are in fact hacked flash drives containing as little as 4GB of real storage. Like counterfeit branded goods, some of these replicate the look, packaging and branding of products such as Kingston, SanDisk, Toshiba and ADATA.

One thing in common with high capacity USB Flash Drives, memory cards and solid state disks is that the raw cost of their NAND flash memory makes up most of the price tag. For example, the price of an entry level 128GB USB flash drive does not vary much from one brand to another and the same goes for a 128GB memory card or a 128GB Solid State Disk (SSD).

The way the fake products work is that when files are stored on them, the hacked firmware will make use of the real capacity. This is usually enough to convince most buyers the drive works fine and to give the seller positive feedback. However, once that real storage is used up, the drive will either start overwriting existing data, create 0-filled files or give an error when any further write requests are made. Unfortunately, the user may not realise something is wrong until they later retrieve files back off only to find that most of their files will not open.

Although Amazon itself appears to sell genuine products, a few of its marketplace sellers clearly appear to be selling fake USB flash drives. The following are first three results we got from a quick search for a 256GB USB stick under £30, including a novelty Iron Man style one:

Amazon Fake 256GB USB flash drives

For comparison, the cheapest 256GB USB stick I could find on Amazon UK that I’m confident is genuine is an iBoutique 256GB USB 3.0 for £89.99, which has over 2100 reviews with a 4.1 out of 5 average rating. So it’s quite likely those fake drives have 16GB or 32GB at the very most of real capacity based on USB flash drives sold for around £13. Most of these reviews clearly indicate they are fake, such as the following verified purchase example from the left leather style USB stick:

Fake USB flash drive Amazon review

To give an example of fake ADATA USB flash drives sold through Amazon, we added the ‘adata’ keyword. One thing we can confirm is that ADATA does not sell either of the following styles in 128GB or larger at this time. So without doubt, both products are counterfeit ADATA products that will not store the rated capacity:

256GB Fake ADATA USB

As the vast majority of USB flash drives and memory cards sold through Amazon are genuine products, generally an unusually low price is a clear indicator of “Too good to be true” product. The US Amazon website appears to have a larger number of fake USB flash drive products, include one claiming to be a Sony 128GB USB stick for $19.99. The Amazon UK website appears to have very few 128GB flash drives that we are confident are fake, although we wouldn’t be surprised if there are some sold priced similar to real products of the equivalent capacity.

Before using any new USB flash drive or memory card product, even from what appears to be a reputable seller, we strongly recommend running a utility that tests the full storage capacity of the drive. One popular utility is H2TestW, which fills the drive to capacity and then reads it back to verify everything is exactly as the same as how it was written. A fake flash product will usually complete the write test, but fail during the verification stage at the point where the real capacity ends. Another advantage of running H2TestW is that it may also identify a defective product.

The following is an example of a Lexar 32GB MicroSD card I had that was intermittently corrupting images. This card was sold by Amazon itself so was most likely a genuine card, but clearly defective from the H2testw test:

Failed_microSD_H2testw

For further reading, we suggest reading this in-depth guide which goes into detail on fake flash drives and memory cards and other tricks sellers use.

Discuss this in our related forum

Click for more news

amazonusb sticks

Click to share

There are 5 comments

alan1476
Administrator, Software Editor and Head of Promotions
Posted on: 05 Jul 14 15:37
    I bought my Lexar 128GB P-10 on Amazon and it was totally legit. So maybe this is limited to third party sellers on Amazon. I only use Amazon, when its Sold by Amazon not fulfilled by Amazon.
    cholla
    MyCE Resident
    Posted on: 05 Jul 14 17:58
      I've never bought a flash drive form Amazon.
      I've purchased many items from Amazon over the years & so far maybe one item wasn't as represented.
      Even from third party sellers.
      That one item was a VHS tape of a movie .
      Supposed to be an original .
      I'm reasonably certain it's a copy.
      I still don't think there is a commercial Region 1 DVD for this movie.
      There certainly wasn't 5 or 6 years ago when I purchased the VHS tape.
      I've made a DVD copy that looks as good as the VHS tape.
      To add to this I can get a UK DVD under a different title .
      Region 2 & PAL . If that one is actually legit & not a copy of the VHS tape.
      The US title is "A Boy Ten Feet Tall".
      The UK title is "Sammy Going South".
      Good old movie if you ever get a chance to watch it.
      http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0056886/
      TSJnachos117
      MyCE Resident
      Posted on: 07 Jul 14 02:01
        BTW, for those who either aren't using Windows, or don't want to use non-free software, there's a similar product called Fight Flash Fraud, also known by the acronym F3. You can get it HERE. This program works with Windows (through Cygwin), Mac OS, and GNU/Linux.

        BTW, this program is protected by the GNU GPL 3.
        debro
        Blown to smitherines
        Posted on: 08 Jul 14 15:35
          I buy neither a data not lexar due to repeated trouble experiences with both of them.

          A 256GB flash drive that is 1/4 the price of everything else?
          Something has to click that it's not right ....
          tmc8080
          MyCE Resident
          Posted on: 09 Jul 14 14:30
            I got a Team 64gb MicroSdxc card for my tablet... the card checked out on capacity.. but lately, I keep seeing the tablet randomly rebooting. Most people in the Asus forums try to tie it to something else. I suspect it's the incompatability with 64gb oversize cards. With my old 16gb card, my tablet almost NEVER used to reboot. Probably for this reason I will likley not get an Asus tablet again.. probably wait & see what's reliable first.

            I think there also might be a gray market where the capacity checks out, but it is a "passable" COUNTERFEIT product! These could end up at reputable sellers such as newegg too. These are harder to diagnose/spot unless you take the time to really analyze what's going on and can pin down that it is indeed a fake. I dunno, I have a lifetime warranty, so not really worried. Most reputable sellers go out of their way to fix problems and many even cover return shipping. This adds higher cost at the reseller level too, making it a longer cycle for flash cards to come down in price. Reputable dealers have an interest in taking care of the customer, while fly-by-nights do not. Amazon is not as good in policing unreputable dealers as ebay-- possibly to the point of it being like buying from China on ebay (which was recently reformed).

            Post your comment

            You need to register before you can comment

            Like us

            Most popular headlines

            TuneIn radio app update disappoints many users - requires social login

            The popular mobile radio app TuneIn receives a lot of negative comments after th...

            WZOR: Windows 9 RTM at the end of 2014

            Russian leaker WZOR has posted information about Windows 9 again, revealing...

            Xbox One owners complain about "horrible noise" coming from console

            Xbox One owners complain about noise coming out of their game console. The issue...

            Leaked Windows 9 screenshots clearly show new Start menu and more

            Several German websites have been provided with new screenshots of Windows 9. Th...

            Kingston HyperX 3.0 64GB USB3 Flash drive review - Speed, build quality and great looks

            • Mon 15 Sep 01:09 by Vroom

            Review: Kingston DT HyperX 3.0 64GB Reviewed by: Antonis Sapanidis P...

            See all headlines
            Follow Myce.com