There are numerous reasons why pirates pirate: a craving for free stuff; anger over price tags; and the pedestrian fact that the content is just there. A new study adds “lack of information” and “my ISP made me do it” to the list.

Sycamore Research & Marketing, on behalf of Australian anti-piracy group the Intellectual Property Awareness Foundation (IPFA), asked consumers (.PDF) a simple question: why do you pirate? The answers revealed a group which unanimously shifted the responsibility of their actions to Internet Service Providers.
“72 percent of people surveyed told us they would stop illegal file-sharing activity if they received a notice from their ISP,” said Gail Grant, CEO of IPAF.
According to the research, respondents also said they believed ISPs were somehow provoking their criminal behavior – “actively encouraging them to share and download illegal content.”
However, ISPs have yet to actually offer customers anything resembling a “Pirate Package” (“Phone, Internet, TV and all the stolen movies you can watch for one low monthly price!”). Similarly, search engines don’t boast a “Pirate it now!” button for those trolling the web for free flicks.
Facetiousness aside, Grant argued that education, not litigation is the best method to cut down on piracy.
“Clearly the solution to a better understanding of the issue will be further education,” said Grant. “ISPs can educate consumers by providing educational and informative notices regarding what’s acceptable online.”
The IPAF study is ostensibly a jumping off point for its own ad campaign aimed at educating viewers that they’re not just skirting the law when they illegally download movies and TV shows. According to Grant, it works.
“In 2010 IPAF launched the ‘Accidental Pirate’ campaign that focused on defining piracy and educating the public on the actions that constitute Movie and TV theft at the everyday and every person level,” said Grant. “The recent research found that 44 percent of people who saw that campaign said it changed their view of the issue.”
Grant said peppering such a serious topic with jokes will resonate with viewers. The IPAF will roll out a new “Accidental Pirate” campaign this month, banking on “unique humor” to better inform consumers about their online choices. Considering the “unique humor” included in ICE’s dramatization of piracy on a busy city sidewalk, the bar is set fairly low.
The IPAF study follows a controversial new “Copyright Alert System” introduced in the U.S. this summer. A collaboration between big media organizations such as the MPAA and equally large telecom companies including Comcast and AT&T, the measure sends up to six emails to customers who illegally accessed online content. Failing that educative approach, the ISPs could enforce stricter “mitigation measures” on offending customers – slower download speeds, for example.
ISPs in Europe came under fire as well. In July, a UK judge ordered British ISP BT to block Newzbin2 from its customers. The usenet index site was previously shutdown in 2010 before it relaunched under new leadership.
The IPAF’s “Accidental Pirate” campaign, which asserts that one in three Australians unintentionally steal content, can be previewed here.
Do you believe ISPs are responsible for piracy? Let us know in the comment section.
3 Comments
Most aussies pirate comment because of:
1) Availability
2) Convenience
3) Quality
4) Price.
5) Lack of enforcement.
And generally in that order.
Physical média is upto 6 months behind the Usa, and online offerings are SD, aussie isps have unmetering agreements only with a single online video service, and pricing is high due to the mystical “Australia Tax“ and lack of competition.
The cinemas in oz cost $17 per person, add $5 fór 3D. The average occer can't afford it, letalone také the entire family! And that's smuggling in your own snacks & drinks.
I can buy dvds/blurays from the uk, and have them arrive 5 days later, often fór 1/3-1/2 the cost of buying local.
The companies here are operating with monopolistic practices, and consumers are revolting.
The standard corporate response is being applied ... The princes are playing up, but don't punish the princes, flog the peasants harder.
I don't claim banks encourage bank robery because they don't try to educate me about the evils of bank robery, but because an ISP doesn't spend tons of spam about downloading, they are encouraging illegal activity? I don't see the logic in that. So many of the industry arguements fail the logic test, and the common sense test. Apperantly they need to teach common sense in law school, and perhaps put it on the bar exam. It would certainly reduce the number of people that pass the bar, at least from the way they act.
About this category
Piracy
- The constant fight against, or enjoyment of pirated movies, music and games: this news covers all that is piracy related, such as lawsuits and P2P services.More about this
Movies
- The movie industry is doing its utter best to trump illegal movie downloads. This section covers the latest movie technologies, distribution methods and what all of this means for you.More about this
Online Video
- More and more people take out their camcorder or mobile phone to eventually share videos on online platforms like YouTube. Learn what online video can do for you!More about this
Most popular headlines
Diablo 3 game fans hit with always-online DRM grief (4)
- Fri 18 May 20:04 by Seán
- Software
it appears that Blizzard underestimated the server capacity required to handle all the gamers, thus resulting in Battle.net servers being overloaded and taken offline at launch. As Diablo III requires the user to be logged in with an uninterrupted internet connection to play, most players were greeted with an "Error 37" on the day of launch, unable to play the game.
CD Projekt says the truth is, DRM doesn't work (2)
- Mon 21 May 22:48 by Seán
- Piracy
In an interview between Forbes and CD Projekt CEO Marcin Iwinski, Iwinski said the truth is that DRM simply does not work. He said the main problem is that the copy protection is cracked within hours of the release of every game, not to mention the money and development wasted to implement it. Those with pirated versions also have a clean and more functional game!
Why not? PNY announces USB drive with whistle (10)
- Wed 23 May 11:48 by DoMiN8ToR
- Uncategorized
It could be possible that there is a scenario where you would have loved to be able to whistle on your USB stick, but we really wonder when. To make
FBI to start special service to spy on online communication (1)
- Thu 24 May 10:11 by DoMiN8ToR
- Computers
Cnet claims that the FBI, the intellige

