Techspot editor: Start Menu’s absence is irrelevant

20 Jul 12 12:28 by in category Software

Techspot editor Matthew DaCarlo has written an editorial on the absence of the Windows 8 start menu (get your replacement here) and why it doesn’t matter. According to him, the major issue people are reporting is that Metro is blocking multi-tasking because it’s blocking access to the desktop. The author wonders what people think is so important about the desktop and goes on to say that Metro is much easier, as live tiles information can be provided directly on the Metro screen, making the information directly available without an additional click.’

Also the amount of applications that can be directly found, without searching or additional clicks is much higher, according to the author. The Windows Start menu can hold a maximum of 30 items, and the author claims that Metro is able to show up to 84 on a single screen.

And, the author ends his article that if you still dislike Metro, you can use Windows 8 without using Metro. Read the entire article here.

12 Comments on Techspot editor: Start Menu’s absence is irrelevant

DukeNukem
Posts: 1606
Posted on: 20 Jul 12 17:19
I think the author gets a weekly cheque from Redmond.
MJPollard
Posts: 51
Posted on: 20 Jul 12 17:55
Quote:
Originally Posted by DukeNukem View Post
I think the author gets a weekly cheque from Redmond.
I was going to say the exact same thing. Wonder if all of these bribery checks to have tech pundits say positive things about Windows 8 is part of what contributed to Microsoft's first-in-its-history quarterly loss...
StormJumper
Posts: 12734
Posted on: 20 Jul 12 18:25
Quote:
Originally Posted by MJPollard View Post
I was going to say the exact same thing. Wonder if all of these bribery checks to have tech pundits say positive things about Windows 8 is part of what contributed to Microsoft's first-in-its-history quarterly loss...
I believe that loss is in regards to their Online ad service not Windows 8 which has not been released for purchase yet from my understanding anyway.

SJ
DukeNukem
Posts: 1606
Posted on: 20 Jul 12 20:42
aQuantive put them in the hole.
BradWright
Posts: 225
Posted on: 20 Jul 12 20:57
I've been saying the exact same thing since the Developer Preview was released. Metro actually makes it easier because everything is right there on the Metro Start screen (I just wish the tiles could be customized more and be made a lot smaller), and just one double click opens whatever you want to open. With the Start menu, you had to click the Start menu, then go through at least one or two additional submenus to get to the program you want to open. But if you don't like Metro, you don't have to use it anyway. Once booted into Windows 8, click the Desktop tile in Metro, and you don't ever need to go back (except to run Apps purchased from the Microsoft Store) if you have icons on the Desktop for the programs/files you use. (Which is how I've always used Windows 7 anyway, and is now how I use Windows 8). And lastly, Metro technically is the Start menu. It's just different because everything is layed out on the screen instead of being buried in pop-up menus and submenus like the previous Windows Start menus, and there's no permanently visible button in the corner to launch it.
MJPollard
Posts: 51
Posted on: 20 Jul 12 22:23
Quote:
Originally Posted by StormJumper View Post
I believe that loss is in regards to their Online ad service not Windows 8 which has not been released for purchase yet from my understanding anyway.
I know that. I was being snarky. And Brad, please spare us your Windows 8 love-fest; you've been singing its praises every chance you get, and we're still not buying what you're selling.
olddancer
Posts: 285
Posted on: 20 Jul 12 22:35
"Techspot editor: Start Menu’s absence is irrelevant"

So too it seems are the wishies and opinions of millions of Windows PAYING CUSTOMERS. Microsloth just posted it's first quaterly loss ever, unless their exectutive get their heads out of their butts, it won't be the last.
Albert
Posts: 5986
Posted on: 20 Jul 12 22:37
Quote:
Originally Posted by BradWright View Post
It's just different because everything is layed out on the screen instead of being buried in pop-up menus and submenus like the previous Windows Start menus, and there's no permanently visible button in the corner to launch it.
Hey! I happen to think best in terms of nested menus. That's why I have my desktop essentially disabled except for quick file storage when moving between drives/partitions/the cloud.

Then again, I've butted heads with folks who wonder how I function.
StormJumper
Posts: 12734
Posted on: 20 Jul 12 22:50
Quote:
Originally Posted by MJPollard View Post
I know that. I was being snarky..
LOL Yeah I figured as much but had to pull your chain anyway.

SJ
iamrocket
Posts: 431
Posted on: 21 Jul 12 01:02
I think I'd like to see the option of having a start button, but its also possible I'm stuck in the old way of thinking. For example, I currently don't have a touch screen monitor, but if I did, it would change the way I interact with my computer in ways I probably haven't even thought of, and I suspect in the next 5 years touchscreen monitors will become mainstream to the point that you will be the odd one if you don't have one. Technology is always changing, maybe its time we change with it.
Then again we're talking MS here, it will take them one more iteration of Windows before they get touchscreen right....
Gummigutta
Posts: 600
Posted on: 21 Jul 12 01:47
Quote:
Originally Posted by iamrocket View Post
Then again we're talking MS here, it will take them one more iteration of Windows before they get touchscreen right....
It's already available in certain versions of W7.
MJPollard
Posts: 51
Posted on: 23 Jul 12 05:45
Quote:
Originally Posted by StormJumper View Post
LOL Yeah I figured as much but had to pull your chain anyway.
Gotcha!
Tell us, what do you think about

Techspot editor: Start Menu’s absence is irrelevant

Most popular headlines

Windows Blue to allow boot to desktop and brings start menu back? (3)

  • Tue 16 Apr 16:12 by DoMiN8ToR
  • Software, Windows 8

The upcoming update of Windows 8 might allow users to boot to the desktop again.

Jobs in US entertainment industry on all-time high - piracy?! (8)

The number of jobs in the film and music industry in the United States has increased despite the claimed negative effects of illegal downloads.

The Piratebay domain moves to Greenland - circumvents blockade (3)

The PirateBay has moved to the domain thepiratebay.gl in fear that their previous domain would be ceased by Swedish authorities

Intel 9 series chipset has native SATA Express (SATA over PCIe) support (2)

A Chinese tech site has posted a picture that reveals details on Intel's 9 series chipset.

See all headlines

Active Commenters