UK ISPs to boot file sharers offline

25 Aug 09 23:36 by Randomus in category Piracy To news archive

The British government today unveiled new rules that may lead to file sharers who repeatedly share copyrighted music and movies to temporarily lose their Internet access.

Despite being heavily criticized by civil rights groups and ISPs, the proposed rules changed from restricting users’ broadband speeds to blocking access to peer-to-peer networks and possibly banishment from the Internet.  If agreed upon by lawmakers, the law could go into effect as early as 2011.

Representatives from the music and movie industries said the British government wasn’t doing enough to reduce file sharing, which led lawmakers to begin brainstorming possible legislation.

gavel

“The government has now reached the view that, if action was deemed necessary, this might be too long to wait given the pressure put on the creative industries by piracy,” the British government said in a statement.  “The new ideas outlined today would potentially allow action to be taken earlier.”

France signed a similar file sharing bill into law in May, also creating a government agency designed specifically to track down Internet users who infringe on music or movie copyrights.  However, legislative issues halted the law from being implemented, and almost two years after French President Nicolas Sarkozy first discussed the law, it still is unknown when enforcement will begin.

In the United States, similar laws have been shot down, even though the Recording Industry Association of America (RIAA) has issued thousands of John Doe lawsuits against alleged file sharers.  Since the current Obama administration has several former RIAA executives — and the DoJ recently enforced a fine against Jammie Thomas — there is concern by some privacy experts that similar laws could be proposed here in the US, in the future.

Similar posts:

8 Comments

BitRate
Posts: 411
Posted on: 26 Aug 09 02:03
This is all about the government supporting those fat corporations and their greedy profiteering. It has nothing to do with protecting copyright. It's all doomed to fail anyway since there is no effective way to distinguish between legal copyrighted content and illegal content. I can see a can of big worms opening up here.
jammydav93
Posts: 10
Posted on: 26 Aug 09 21:29
Agreed,

I dont seem to see any of the media telling people that downloading any files is legal as long as you have an original of the file, e.g. If I have an xbox 360 game, I am legally allowed to download a backup from wherever
pipemanid
Posts: 5212
Posted on: 26 Aug 09 22:14
Quote:
Originally Posted by jammydav93 View Post
Agreed,

I dont seem to see any of the media telling people that downloading any files is legal as long as you have an original of the file, e.g. If I have an xbox 360 game, I am legally allowed to download a backup from wherever
Do you happen to have a link to prove this statement?
I just searched copyright law and it only allows backups for archival purposes and doesn't address downloading backups...
jammydav93
Posts: 10
Posted on: 26 Aug 09 22:21
No its just thats what i've always heard, although it should be if its not

Anyhow its very hard for them to proove your a pirate,, and the ISPs are hugely against this idea as it means cutting off their own customers and by doing so losing a lot of money,

This law will be imposed, but only a few people will be made example of and it wont take off
pipemanid
Posts: 5212
Posted on: 26 Aug 09 22:24
"Copyright law provides that a person must have permission to make a copyrighted work (such as a sound recording) available for download on the internet. Doing so (i.e. uploading) without permission of the copyright owner (in the case of a sound recording, the record label) is against the law, regardless of whether the music was originally obtained legally or illegally by the uploader."
http://www.bpi.co.uk/digital-music/a...line-faqs.aspx
Arachne
Posts: 29881
Posted on: 26 Aug 09 23:21
Quote:
Originally Posted by jammydav93 View Post
...and the ISPs are hugely against this idea as it means cutting off their own customers and by doing so losing a lot of money,
Yup....the fact that so many ISPs are against it makes me wonder how all this will pan out.
AmiWolf
Posts: 75
Posted on: 27 Aug 09 18:05
Will there ever be an end to the filesharing process? Doubtful.
Is throwing people off their internet going to do anything more than piss some people off and watch as the fireworks start from those that have the capabilities to hack, slash and worm their way onto the varied ISP's? See Pirate Bay article.

Sooner or later it's going to come down to whom has the bigger d_ _ k... The aftermath will leave the rest of us scratching our collective heads and wondering, "Now what?!?!"
Pharchops
Posts: 13
Posted on: 29 Aug 09 05:42
Britain was the birthplace of the Luddite movement and George Orwell (1984),so the idea of it fast becoming a backward,facsist,Orwellian nightmare does'nt surprise me."Regulation",is the tool of first resort for idiots who lack the mental capacity to think "outside the square",or the creative ability to envisage the future and connect the dots.I honestly feel for the artists,the ability to make a living doing what you love,is damn near a human right.But,,,getting your "Big Brother" to beat the crap out of people with the proverbial sledgehammer before you've exhausted
many of the options,is far from forward thinking.
The perfect society has no need of law.
Connect those dots.

Post a comment

Hello guest,
default
To benefit from all extra features you need to log in or sign up.

About this category

Piracy

  • The constant fight against, or enjoyment of pirated movies, music albums and games can be found here. This news channel brings the latest on law suits that are piracy related, busted duplicators and P2P services. More about this

Most popular headlines

Microsoft: PS3's Blu-ray is a burden (4)

  • Thu 18 Mar 00:00 by JaredNewman
  • Blu-Ray writers & players, Game Consoles

Microsoft's Xbox product director Aaron Greenberg said the Xbox 360's lack of a Blu-ray player has actually been crucial to the console's success.

Sony's new ad mocks Wii, Xbox 360 (3)

  • Sat 20 Mar 10:02 by Randomus
  • Game Consoles

A week after publicly unveiling its PlayStation 3 Move motion controller at GDC, Sony has launch a new ad attacking the Microsoft Xbox 360 and Nintendo Wii game consoles.

Spain allows P2P, link-sharing of copyrighted works (10)

As long as no profits are made, it's legal to share copyrighted material through peer-to-peer transfers or link to it through a Web site, a Spanish court ruled.

Sony considers discontinuing the PSP Go (4)

  • Thu 18 Mar 02:00 by Randomus
  • Game Consoles

It's possible Sony will pull the plug on its struggling PSP Go mobile gaming unit, as it has become obvious the company dropped the ball a bit in the mobile gaming business.

See all headlines

Active Commenters