NeroLINUX Review

Author

Dee
Senior Administrator and Reviewer
Article posted 12 Jun 05 18:23

Conclusion

Positives and Negatives:


While using this program a number of points both positive and negative came up. These are listed below for easy reference.

Positives:

  • Easy to use
  • Simple and elegant user interface
  • Solid application (never crashed once)
  • Everything worked as it should
  • It’s different
  • For registered Nero 6 (Windows) users, NeroLINUX is free.

Negatives:

  • A lack of Audio and Video wizards makes Audio and Video creation less than simple
  • General lack of features
  • Some dialogs could do with a makeover
  • No label creation feature
  • No Nero InfoTool or CD-Speed utilities.

Conclusion:


NeroLINUX has a fairly basic feature set, but the features it does have, all work very well.

During the review period the application proved solid and robust and never crashed once. It does however lack a lot of features that one has come to expect from a burn application. There are no wizards to guide you through, and hold your hand while you create your masterpiece. Some may see this as a bonus. Some will not be able to manage without those wizards.

Having had a few weeks too get used to using NeroLINUX and creating a few CD and DVD discs. One thing that kept running through my mind was ‘if only”. This led me to creating a wish list of features I would like to see added to NeroLINUX.

  1. When creating a new compilation: it would be nice to be able to select the project type like the Windows version of Nero
  2. File conversion would also be a nice addition: for example being able to convert MP3 files straight out of the box would be very nice indeed.
  3. Video authoring of some kind is badly needed: If Nero Vision Express could be ported to Linux and included with NeroLINUX, this would boost this applications appeal by miles.
  4. The now legendary Nero Toolkit would also be very useful; Nero InfoTool and CD-Speed were sadly missed during this review.

Final Word:


nero_linux_logo (3643 Byte) One must keep in mind that NeroLINUX is still in development and this is still a very early version.

What we have so far is a solid and robust application, it works well, and it does what it claims to do. A big plus at the moment is NeroLINUX is free to Nero 6 users. Even if you don’t own Nero 6, the NeroLINUX download will allow you to trial the application and see if it fits your needs.

One thing we can be sure of. When big players like Nero take the Linux operating system serious enough to port its premium burn application across to the Linux platform. We can be sure of great things to come.

In summing up:

NeroLINUX offers a genuine alternative to having to use Windows to produce CD and DVD discs. During the review period I enjoyed using NeroLINUX. This is one application I will most definitely keep on my Linux PC and look forward to updates to NeroLINUX with anticipation. I guess if this application grows to anything near the sophistication of its Windows parent application, then Nero will start to charge for it. Let us hope the price can kept to a reasonable amount.

The NeroLINUX homepage can be found here and Nero homepage at this link. You can also discuss this software in this forum thread.

Thanks to:


MMORE International B.V. – The Netherlands for providing the CD-R media used in this review.

 

 

Verbatim GmbH – Germany for providing the CD-R media used in this review.

4 Comments

dansmug
Posts: 2421
Posted on: 14 Jun 05 18:55
Some comments: - Taste is personnal, but still. 95% of the comments I've read about NeroLinux didn't find the interface elegant A recent version of GTK or Qt would be a serious improvement. - What's so positive about the fact that NeroLinux is free if you have the Windows-version? If I want to use it, I'll have to buy an expensive Windows-version with far more features. A version I will never use. So that maks NeroLinux really expensive! - Solid application?! Under Windows, not crashing would be a positive point :B (That's a joke before some starts flaming) Apart from that, good review. Glad to see there is some interest in Linux-burning. Will you make a K3B-review too?
[edited by dansmug on 14.06.2005 18:56]
Visitor
Posts: 38
Posted on: 18 Oct 05 16:40
Usless, sead my Datawrite was TDK !
dakhaas
Posts: 1951
Posted on: 26 Oct 05 20:26
Sorry to say but Visitor but I think your incorrect. DVD identifier does work. DVD identifier identifies disc's based on MID. I assume that the datawrite disc is a so called datawrite titanium disc based on the posts on the forum. The Datawrite Titanium disc is based on TDK's specifications and was made by a manufacturer who also makes this TDK media for TDK. However while this disc was supposed to be made with TDK technology and based on TDK's specification. There is no guarantee about that the quality will be as good as the TDK media sold through TDK because of the fact that budget brands may use lower graded media. The identification of the code is correct at least up to the level as the software goes. In case of technology outsourcing DVD identifier identifies the original technology supplier of the stamper. Which means that there is no difference between the disc's made by the original owner of the code or the party who manufactured the media for them in case of the official products. Because these product s are made according to the standards and specifications of the owner of the code. Now for the nitpicking people who say that dvd identifier can not identify products correctly with borrowed codes. (like I said already above.) In case of officially borrowed codes. 1 Officially borrowed codes mean that the media has to perform based on the specification of the technology supplier. Which means that there is no difference between the disc's made by the original owner of the code or the party who manufactured the media for them in case of the official retail product. In case of code abuse. 1 Usseing codes without permission is illegal ! (The original owner can take action against the abuse of the MID.)- It's a so called fake product. 2 However up to some level it is possible to recognize fakes with DVD identifier in some cases.* (So even in that case DVD identifier proofs to be a valuable tool. * example as shown in the german computer magazine C't 14 2005.(27-6-2005) I hope this clears up the case if people still have questions then ask them on the forum.
[edited by dakhaas on 26.10.2005 20:33]
robguy
Posts: 32
Posted on: 10 Dec 05 14:27
Generally agree with the reviewer of this software; however, I would use the term "primitive" to describe the interface. Nothing elegant about it. As for free ... as a registered Nero 6 customer, Ahead never offered me a free copy, but happily accepted my money for a serial number. And yes, it does need more work. The venerable K3B has more going for it than NeroLinux.

Post a comment

Hello guest,
default
To benefit from all extra features you need to log in or sign up.