Sony BWU-200S Blu-ray Rewritable Drive Review

Author

KIPPER
Retired Moderator & Reviewer
Article posted 12 Jan 08 05:13

DVD-R/RW Writing Performance

 

DVD-R media compatibility and write quality

As with the +R media, for these tests we will be using the Lite-On DH20A3P  drives along with Nero’s CD-DVDspeed to measure the disc quality. We will also be using the BenQ DW1650 along with Nero CD-DVDSpeed for our read-back tests.

Here is what we discovered:

Disc Quality Scan at 4X with Lite-on Drive

TRT with BenQ DW-1650

A dip in the TRT at the 1.4 mark; overall quality was good with this media.


Disc Quality Scan at 4X with Lite-on Drive

TRT with BenQ DW-1650

Good results with this Phillips media.


 

Disc Quality Scan at 4X with Lite-on Drive

TRT with BenQ DW-1650

As we can see, there were some PIF spikes, however, the TRT reflects a smooth read back curve when burned at 16X.


Disc Quality Scan at 4X with Lite-on Drive

TRT with BenQ DW-1650

The Sony BWU-200S performed very well with this media from Verbatim.


Disc Quality Scan at 4X with Lite-on Drive

TRT with BenQ DW-1650

The Sony BWU-200S did very good, burning this Taiyo Yuden 8X media.


Disc Quality Scan at 4X with Lite-on Drive

TRT with BenQ DW-1650

A block of PIF which coincides with the dip in the TRT; still overall an OK burn with this Verbatim 8X media.


DVD-RW media compatibility and write quality

We used the same test procedures as in our DVD-R tests.

Here are our results.

Disc Quality Scan at 4X with Lite-on Drive

TRT with BenQ DW-1650

High spike of (9) on PIF, otherwise the Sony BWU-200S would have done a much better job with this media.

Summary

Overall, the Sony BWU-200S did a good job with our DVD-R/RW test media; we would have liked to have seen better performance with our DVD-RW test media.

Let’s head on to the next page where we will test DVD R DL writing performance and quality……


10 Comments

guest
Posts: 15284
Posted on: 13 Jan 08 00:29
I have owned this burner for about a week and a half. So far, so good - no coasters burned yet. A good thing with blank media at $15-20USD. My Panasonic DMP-BD10 home player has no problems playing home HD videos burned with the Sony burner. Check out your player's format capability before burning any discs with any BD burner. Some players (like my Panny) will play only BDMV format; some players will play BDAV. This burner will burn either, but some burning software won't support BDAV. I am using Ulead Movie Factory with the HD add-in; it will burn either format. Others have noted that the Sony's drawer won't fit thru a normal cutout - that was the situation with my Dell XPS400. Tried trimming out the hole in the Dell; gave up and mounted the burner in an external enclosure. Overall, thumbs up even at the $600USD price.
Coconut
Posts: 173
Posted on: 14 Jan 08 00:41
Harry, what is the enclosure that you use, please?
guest
Posts: 15284
Posted on: 15 Jan 08 01:58
hmm, as in most of Kip's reviews there are no pictures of the inside of the drive, which in my opinion tells us a lot more about the technology used inside. Not at all interested in how the left and right side of the drive looks like. :c
heroineworshipper
Posts: 41
Posted on: 15 Jan 08 02:23
Only $500 more to go until it's affordable.
DeadMan
Posts: 1629
Posted on: 18 Jan 08 01:43
Cheaper per gigabyte to get an HDD and download x264 rips
guest
Posts: 15284
Posted on: 20 Jan 08 11:56
Ouch! $600, well. it IS a blue ray drive after all.. Yes dvds were crazy expensive too in their day.. but then again the format war is in the midst of Gettysburg battle. So it won't be long before one camp caves in.. and popularity forces price redux.
guest
Posts: 15284
Posted on: 20 Jan 08 22:53
"Harry, what is the enclosure that you use, please?" It is actually a cannabilized external one for a DVD drive. External 5.25" SATA enclosures are a little hard to find and are well over $50 when you do. I had to run a power cable and SATA cable out of the back of the PC and the back of the external enclosure. The enclosure I use has a power switch that is not maintained and the PC showed drive not available when booting if the power was not on. So, I ran an cable from the PC power supply. Kinda junky doing it that way, but it works.
guest
Posts: 15284
Posted on: 08 Feb 08 05:56
The LG GGW-H20L is selling for about $400 on ebay. It can write BD-R at 6x though 6x media seems not available yet. I tried TDK BD-R 25GB 2x certified media using the bundled software power2go. It was recognized as 4x by the software and finished writing a full disc in about 25 minutes. The above review didn't mention TDK BD-R. I wonder how BWU200S would perform with this media.
guest
Posts: 15284
Posted on: 17 Jul 08 22:49
Does it work under 64-bit Windows (WinXP Pro x64 or Vista 64)?
guest
Posts: 15284
Posted on: 18 Sep 08 10:46
Installed in my tower last night and Vista 64 had some issues with the software on installation. had to choose not to install parts of the package but once the rest were installed and upgraded the player for Blu-Ray commercial compatibility the rest of the software installed fine. no problems since then.

Post a comment

Hello guest,
default
To benefit from all extra features you need to log in or sign up.