Ideal DVD Copy Review

Author

Wombler
Moderator and Reviewer
Article posted 30 Nov 11 20:54

Introduction & Software Installation

 

Review: Ideal DVD Copy
Reviewed by: Wombler
Provided by: Ideal DVD Software

 

Ideal DVD Software was kind enough to send me a number of their various movie copy software products for review. In this particular review we will be having a look at Ideal DVD Copy and seeing how well this product looks and performs.

Ideal DVD Software

Ideal DVD Software was founded in 2005 and is a professional DVD software developer specialising in movie copy and video conversion software. They offer a range of products including programs dedicated to converting video for use on computers, media streamers and various popular mobile devices. Further information about Ideal DVD Software can be found on their website.


Test PC Specifications

First things first, so here are the specifications for the test PC.

  • Intel Core i7 860 Quad Core Processor – Socket LGA1156
  • ASUS P7P55 LX Motherboard
  • Windows 7 Home Premium Edition 64bit
  • 8GB DDR3 Ram
  • Twin SATA 2 1TB Hard drives (in a RAID 0 striped configuration)
  • ATI Radeon HD5770 Graphics Card
  • Samsung SH-B083L Combined Blu-ray ROM & DVD Writer
  • NZXT Hush Silent Brushed Aluminium ATX Midi Tower Case in Black with 700W Power Supply

Software Installation

There is no packaging associated with this program since it is only available as a download from the Ideal DVD Copy website and consists of a zipped executable installation file.

I unzipped and ran the file and the installation proceeds using the familiar Microsoft installation routines.

Following acceptance of the standard Licence Agreement the program then offers you a chance to select where you want it installed.

You are then asked to specify the name and location of the Start Menu folder.

Having been asked whether you want to create a desktop icon the installation commences.

This completes very quickly and you are then given the opportunity to either launch the program straight away or simply exit the completed installation routine.

Overall the installation is simple, effective and very straightforward. It uses sensible defaults and operates flawlessly so I can’t find any fault with this.

So following this promising start let’s go to the next page and examine the main program….

19 Comments

Kerry56
Posts: 12736
Posted on: 30 Nov 11 22:49
That was quite a good review Wombler. Thanks.

I'm a little surprised the transcoder could give acceptable results from such a difficult, and long source. This is the type of movie I would always recommend using an encoder instead. But it does seem to indicate that their transcoder has been advanced beyond some of the earlier programs, and will prove to be worthwhile on movies that require smaller amounts of compression.
Moonlight79
Posts: 204
Posted on: 01 Dec 11 02:32
Thanks, Wombler. A great job!
Moonlight79
Posts: 204
Posted on: 01 Dec 11 02:35
About the skin, I'll accept your suggestion and make the ideal_blue as the default. And I'm considering designing a complete new GUI.
bean55
Posts: 5946
Posted on: 01 Dec 11 16:07
Great Review Wombler

I tested it on Smurfs last night and I noticed it had a Fuzzy look through out the movie.
I will have to test this movie with other software when they are able to see the results.

It was simple to install and use and I will be testing it with other movies soon to see if the Fuzzy look shows on them.

Again Great review Wombler
alan1476
Posts: 17234
Posted on: 02 Dec 11 00:05
No fuzzy look here bean55, try it again. Any by the way Womblers review was the best. Thanks Wombler for indroducing us to this software.
Wombler
Posts: 6259
Posted on: 02 Dec 11 09:36
Quote:
Originally Posted by Kerry56 View Post
That was quite a good review Wombler. Thanks.

I'm a little surprised the transcoder could give acceptable results from such a difficult, and long source. This is the type of movie I would always recommend using an encoder instead. But it does seem to indicate that their transcoder has been advanced beyond some of the earlier programs, and will prove to be worthwhile on movies that require smaller amounts of compression.
Thanks Kerry.

It's all very subjective and down to personal judgement but no program so far has produced results that I wouId would regard as truly acceptable with this movie (including a full re-encode) although it's a severe test.

I also produced a full re-encode as the benchmark for quality purposes and used this to assist in the comparison between the output from my previous favourite transcoder and Ideal DVD Copy.

In that context and within the parameters specified in the review I think Ideal DVD Copy stands up very well indeed.

It's always difficult to objectively describe quality in words as people's opinions are always different but that's another plus for choosing 'Saving Private Ryan' as a very large number of people will have this title and will be able to run the same tests for themselves.


Wombler
Wombler
Posts: 6259
Posted on: 02 Dec 11 09:50
@Alan1476 – Thanks Alan.

@Moonlight79 – Thanks and glad to hear you’re changing the defaults. The interface is very clean and simple to use and that was the only very slight problem I had.

@bean55 – Transcoders often have difficulties with animated movies and I’ve noticed this in the past even with a full re-encode on some of the ‘South Park’ episodic DVDs. I haven’t checked out ‘Smurfs’ yet but I’m assuming this is an animated movie.


Wombler
bean55
Posts: 5946
Posted on: 02 Dec 11 13:36
Yes Wombler it is a mixed one ( animated and real people )

When I redid it last night it came out different, now the first 10 minutes is real pixated and then the rest was fuzzy still. I will be trading out my disc tonight and then retry tomorrow.
I think I may have a bad press one.
bean55
Posts: 5946
Posted on: 03 Dec 11 05:56
Looks like my disc was a bad pressing
The disc that comes in the Combo BluRay/DVD worked just fine.
Wombler
Posts: 6259
Posted on: 04 Dec 11 17:45
Quote:
Originally Posted by bean55 View Post
Looks like my disc was a bad pressing
The disc that comes in the Combo BluRay/DVD worked just fine.
Glad to hear you traced the problem.

Were you happy enough with the results?


Wombler
bean55
Posts: 5946
Posted on: 05 Dec 11 14:15
Yes I was
I bought the program
durkinjt
Posts: 833
Posted on: 05 Dec 11 19:49
I bought the program yeterday, used it 5x's already, seems like a great product at a great price.
alan1476
Posts: 17234
Posted on: 05 Dec 11 20:31
Quote:
Originally Posted by durkinjt View Post
I bought the program yeterday, used it 5x's already, seems like a great product at a great price.
Wise choice durknjt. Please let us know what you think. I hope you mentioned MyCE when you bought it.
alan1476
Posts: 17234
Posted on: 05 Dec 11 20:33
Quote:
Originally Posted by bean55 View Post
Yes I was
I bought the program
You are also a wise man bean55, please mention that you bought this program because of Womblers review on MyCE.com
Wombler
Posts: 6259
Posted on: 05 Dec 11 21:27
Glad to hear you're happy with this program guys.

If you've any more detailed opinions, once you've used the software for a while, start a new thread and let us know as we'd all be interested to hear your thoughts.


Wombler
cholla
Posts: 4033
Posted on: 05 Dec 11 21:30
Since at my request the merge question was moved to its own thread .

I want to give cudos again here to Wombler for a good review.
Moonlight79
Posts: 204
Posted on: 06 Dec 11 08:47
Glad to hear the positive comment about our program.

And we offer a discount price for the members here, don't forget to get it. Visit http://club.myce.com/f178/coupon-cod...s-here-324689/ to learn the detailed information about the discount.
moljude1
Posts: 93
Posted on: 22 Jan 12 22:58
I have bought this software too the best I have had so now i delete all other burning software on my pc good IDEAL HEEEHEEEE
Wombler
Posts: 6259
Posted on: 23 Jan 12 20:28
Quote:
Originally Posted by moljude1 View Post
I have bought this software too the best I have had so now i delete all other burning software on my pc good IDEAL HEEEHEEEE
Glad to hear you're happy with your choice Jude.

It's great software IMO.


Wombler

Post a comment

Hello guest,
default
To benefit from all extra features you need to log in or sign up.

About this category

Movies

  • The movie industry is doing its utter best to trump illegal movie downloads. This section covers the latest movie technologies, distribution methods and what all of this means for you.More about this

Software

  • Sometimes your products need a software update to protect or let it run better. Here you'll find the latest hardware-related software updates.More about this