SSD vs HDD Video – Booting & everyday tasks

Like deciding whether to invest in a pricey heavy duty item over a cheaper low cost version that does the same job, a Solid State Disk is one of those things one really needs to look at the long-term benefit.

With a Solid State Disk, its benefit really shows after a few months of everyday use where it maintains its “like new installation” performance, while a hard disk based installation typically slows down the more it is used, especially when installing and updating software. From experience of seeing various user’s installations, a typical 1 year old HDD based installation takes 2 or more minutes to boot and settle before it’s usable or even longer if the user doesn’t carry out regular maintenance. Often it comes to the point where it’s quicker to simply backup, flatten and reinstall!

So we took our near 4-month old Windows 7 installation, mirrored it to a high end consumer Hard Disk and made a video comparing some everyday tasks including booting, multitasking, ZIP extraction and updates. The OS is pretty cluttered, as this PC has been in everyday use for roughly 5 hours a day since October ’09. Note that we only use the SSD for the OS and applications, as the data (e.g. video, photos, etc.) which gets little benefit with an SSD can be stored on a hard disk. In fact, we have our desktop, documents and e-mail profiles redirected to the hard disk to also reduce SSD space usage.

For the SSD, we used the OCZ Agility 60GB, which is a decent performing SSD with an average price in the 60GB capacity SSD range. For the hard disk, we used the Western Digital Caviar Black 1TB (7200RPM, 32MB cache), which is considered one of the fastest consumer hard disks available according to many product reviews of it. We also tweaked the cloned partition by resizing it to 100GB to assist defragging. By using just 10% the capacity for the first (and only) partition, this reduces seek times and places the data in the fastest area. Finally, we performed a deep optimise with IObit Smart Defrag as the partition was in a heavily fragmented state due to the SSD source never being defragged.


Watch in HD

ADVERTISEMENT

In this video we carry out the following comparisons (SSD shown in PIP):

  • Windows 7 boot-up
  • Then launch 14 applications
  • Then launch 3 apps in XP Mode
  • Upgrade OpenOffice 3.1 to 3.2
  • Extract a ZIP (3,914 files/365MB)
  • Install 5 Windows Updates
  • Disk Fragmentation
  • A Gatso Speed Camera

Note that the boot/multitasking part of the above comparison video was retaken at the time of comparing the two drives due to some applications being updated since the original video. If you would like to see our original SSD video, which shows just the SSD booting & multitasking, follow this link.

We also have an in-depth review of the OCZ Agility 120GB SSD Review.

For other in-depth SSD reviews, see the ‘Read first’ threads in our Solid State Drives discussion forum.

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT